Date: Mon, 3 Sep 2001 14:24:54 -0400
Reply-To: Walt Spak <wnsopc3@3RDM.NET>
Sender: Vanagon Mailing List <vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com>
From: Walt Spak <wnsopc3@3RDM.NET>
Subject: Re: Oranage coolant leak?
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"
Malcolm & list,
Let me start by saying that I do have a really good flame suit.
I did some major work on my 91 GL about a year & 1/2 ago including a Boston
Bob engine.
I also replaced:
all of the hoses
thermostat housing
thermostat
plastic water distribution piece on right
expansion tank
all metal water pipes
all hose clamps w/ OEM clamps from dealer
water pump
heater core
I charged the system with orange antifreeze (Prestone 5/150 Extended Life).
With in the first year, I experienced 2 leaking hoses where they clamp on
to metal pipes, a leaking oil cooler, a leaking thermostat housing, and a
leaking water pump. I was ready to scrap the bus.
This spring, my friend & I finished restoring a 1955 Lancia Spider ( I did
the engine, he the rest). Since it has an aluminum engine, I filled it with
the same Prestone. We fought very small leaks for weeks. In the end, we
replaced the antifreeze with good old fashion green antifreeze and all of
the leaks went away.
Now for the part of this post that may raise some response. I have had
heads off of no fewer than 5 Vanagons (3 - 1.9 , 2 - 2.1) and all have had
green anti freeze. I have seen the same situation in every one. In every
place that the antifreeze touches the aluminum, there is no corrosion.
None. The only place that the corrosion exists, is under the rubber head
gasket. I think that the antifreeze concerns lead from the belief that the
coolant works it's way under the gasket and causes the corrosion. I don't
believe it. I think that the heat / cool cycles cause condensation to form
under the gasket, which causes the corrosion. Antifreeze contains
anti-corrosion additives, condensation does not. Use it locally for short
trips with long periods of sitting in between and I expect the corrosion
will happen sooner.
My conclusions are that the orange anti freeze does find leaks easier than
the green and is not necessary. I do think that frequent changing of anti
freeze is helpful over the long haul because the anti corrosion additives
will break down over time.
I must add that I have no experience with the VW antifreeze at all.
Walt Spak
Pittsburgh, PA.
wnsopc3@3rdm.net
----- Original Message -----
From: Malcolm Stebbins <MSTEBBIN@MSVU1.MSVU.CA>
To: <vanagon@GERRY.VANAGON.COM>
Sent: Monday, September 03, 2001 12:21 PM
Subject: Oranage coolant leak?
> When I bought my 91 vanagon, it had the green coolant
> in it and the van had NO coolant leaking problems.
> About 3 months ago I put in the (expensive) VW Orange
> Coolant and I have had no end of coolant leaking out of
> many hose clamps etc. Even the heads are weeping
> orange coolant and it is a new (50,000 kms) engine.
>
> My (trusted) mechanic says that orange coolant has
> "smaller molecules", or some such, and that if I go back
> to green coolant the heads will not weep and I will have
> fewer other coolant problems.
>
> Do any of you guys have any input on this? Malcolm
> Stebbins