Date:         Wed, 6 Aug 2003 14:56:54 -0400
Reply-To:     vw4x4@FYI.NET
Sender:       Vanagon Mailing List <vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com>
From:         Eric Zeno <vw4x4@FYI.NET>
Subject:      Re: JD Power and VW
Comments: To: Fred Brittain <vanpire@CITLINK.NET>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed

I have had little or no respect for JD Powers,  Consumer reports or any
of these serves.   These are for the average person who can not
change a flat tire.   We are not average people here.  If you don't
get your hands dirty, keep reading, and believing.
                                                                 Eric



Fred Brittain wrote:

>Yo,
>
>Anybody looked up VW's on JD Power. They don't seem to think too much
>about our elite German, Mexican vehicles.
>
>I have wanted a VW TDI since I first found out about them. I just ran
>a long term quality check on JD involving several cars. 1) '90 Vanagon
>(oldest listed), 98 Jetta, 98 Passat, 98 Beetle (my choice of commuter
>replacement), '94 Geo Metro (my present commuter vehicle).  The ratios
>represent rating over possible of five.
>
>Results: mechanical dependability     accessory dependability
>body and interior
>
>90 Vanagon       3/5
>2/5                                    3/5
>
>98 Beetle            3/5
>2/5                                   2/5
>
>98 Jetta              2/5
>3/5                                    2/5
>
>98 Passat            2/5
>2/5                                     2/5
>
>94 Geo Metro    3/5
>3/5                                      3/5
>
>This is set to seventy column so hopefully it is legible. Interesting.
>I can tell you I bought the Geo new, driven 100k miles and have done
>only routine maintenance.
>
>I WANT a TDI. New Beetles are the most easily accessible (available
>and affordable). I would appreciate any feedback, especially regarding
>the overall quality of a '98 New Beetle TDI. (that is the hitherto
>unstated purpose of this post)
>
>I apologize profusely if this is considered off-topic. It is,
>however,  of interest to me that the '90 Vanagon is considered second
>in reliability only to the Geo.  Go figure.
>
>Fred
>89 Westy
>shopping for TDI
>Moab, UT
>
>
>
>