Date: Fri, 21 Jan 2005 11:01:43 -0500
Reply-To: Don in North Carolina <Don_Dixon@BELLSOUTH.NET>
Sender: Vanagon Mailing List <vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com>
From: Don in North Carolina <Don_Dixon@BELLSOUTH.NET>
Subject: Engine dies, now which distributor?? (long winded)
Content-Type: text/plain; format=flowed; charset="iso-8859-1";
reply-type=response
Hello all!
Here is my sad tale of woe:
The van - 1988 Vanagon GL
The symptoms - While driving, engine would cut out / die for a second,
tachometer immediately goes to 0. Looked around in engine bay, didn't find
anything. Figured I would live with it unless it got worse. Well, it got
worse - while driving at ~55 MPH, engine dies and stays dead. Coast off the
road, try to restart - cranks over but no joy. Go back, look around the
engine compartment, wiggle wires (a technical specialty of mine) try to
restart, cranks but no start. Look in the back again, still don't see
anything, try to start - starts right up!, runs like nothing had ever
happened. Drive home, runs fine, no issues. Do a search on the archives,
find a comment from Joy about her issues and how they had found the plug
loose going to the black box (CDI box above coil on left hand side of engine
bay). Push on my plug, moves about 1/8 inch and feel a click - Ah hah says
I! Next few days uneventful, van runs well and all seems fine (you can see
what's coming, can't you?). Out on a drive, speed about 45 - engine dies,
tachometer goes to 0. This time it would not start, and after ~45 minutes
of trying battery is low enough that it obviously isn't going to start. Tow
home (thanks AAA+). Pull battery and charge. Next morning, put battery
back in van (battery is ~8 months old, BTW), on second attempt, van starts
and runs fine. Intermittent problems, the bane of troubleshooters
everywhere!
The solution (hopefully) - looked in archives (I used different keywords
this time), found several mentions of the same type of issue and all were
reported to be due to a defective Hall Effect sensor in the distributor.
Now I know that the sensor is available separately, but I am planning to
replace the complete distributor (piece of mind issue). The complete
distributor is about $70 more than the sensor itself (not counting the new
o-rings and anything else you find wrong when working on the distributor).
The new problem - there are at least three different part numbers listed for
the distributor:
0.986.237.639, 0237.520.046 and 025.905.205AG. It appears that the last two
numbers may be for the 90-91 models. I know that the distributor caps and
rotors are different for the 90-91 models, but are the distributors still
interchangeable with the old ones - in other words, are the specs the same
and will the hall effect plug fit? What did they change, to "improve" the
newer distributors?
TIA,
Don in Reidsville, NC
1987 Vanagon GL Syncro (Suzie) - For Sale!
1988 Vanagon GL (Sylvia)
|