Date: Wed, 5 Sep 2007 00:53:19 -0400
Reply-To: Kim Brennan <kimbrennan@MAC.COM>
Sender: Vanagon Mailing List <vanagon@gerry.vanagon.com>
From: Kim Brennan <kimbrennan@MAC.COM>
Subject: Tires (by one reviewer)
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII; delsp=yes; format=flowed
One of the problems with review pages (such as Larry Chase's) is that
few folk have had a chance to directly compare one type of tire
versus another, except over many years difference.
In the last 2 years I have put a variety of tires on my vanagon
Syncros. All more than met the specs for Syncro vanagons.
This included the BFGoodrich All Terrain T/A ko tires (215/75R15,
235/75R15), Vredestein Comtrac (205/65R15), Vredestein Winter Comtrac
(225/70R15) and Nokian Hakkapeliitta CS (215/75R16).
The Vredestein Comtrac is the quietest. The Vredestein Winter Comtrac
is just about as quiet. When new the BFG's are quiet, but as they
wear they definitely get louder. The Nokian's are distinctly louder
than the Comtrac or Winter Comtrac, but not as noisy as worn BFG's.
One of my biggest loves about the BFG is the rim protector design of
the tire. Over the years in various cars, I've scraped my rims on
curbs. The design of the BFG tire just about makes this impossible. I
also like the aggressive tread design of the BFG. Less to like is how
quickly they wear (and get noisy). But they have great traction in
the snow and are great on dirt roads.
The Comtrac is a van street tire plain and simple. It's not designed
for winter use, but is a good sturdy tire and nice and quiet.
The Winter Comtrac has noticably softer compound than the Comtrac,
and really is intended for winter use only (though I've used them in
the summer as well). In snow and ice they are fantastic. They aren't
so good on dirt and mud (at least in comparison to the BFGs).
The Nokian Hakka's are my latest tires. The tire compound is harder
than the Winter Comtrac, and they are distinctly all season tires,
but rated for snow and ice. I've heard (but can't yet confirm) that
they are truly excellent in the snow. If they are as good as the
Winter Comtracs then the added noise factor may be tolerable enough
to use them all year round. Certainly their load factor is as good or
higher than the Comtrac and Winter Comtrac at the same tire size.
Both the Nokian and Winter Comtrac are directional tires (a minor
pain to deal with if you rotate your tires yourself.) The Comtrac and
BFGs aren't.
The 235/75R15 BFGs are just a little too big for an unmodified 14"
Syncro (rubbing on compression of the suspension, but no rubbing for
just driving about.) The 215/75R16 Nokian's are nearly the same size,
but have no rubbing issues, even under compression.