Date: Wed, 12 Oct 94 11:38:10 EDT
Sender: Vanagon Mailing List <vanagon@vanagon.com>
From: dcarment@ccs.carleton.ca (David Carment)
Subject: Re: Originator Names
David Schwarze writes:
>
> DerekDrew@aol.com writes:
> >
> > I have begun receiving messages which indicate the original sender as sender
> > rather than the vanagon list as sender. I don't know if this is something
> > Gerry is doing or if my AOL software has begun doing this.
>
> I haven't seen anything like that with ELM (Unix mailer)
Nor have I with ELM (except for messages that I send which come back
multiple recipients.
>
> > Either way, it isn't such a good idea. When I hit my reply button the message
> > might go back to that individual rather than to the whole list.
>
> I prefer it that way. You can still send a group reply if you want, which
> would go back to the list. Having ALL replies sent to the list makes it
> very hard to send private mail as a response.
>
> > About 1/2 of the messages on this list have no business being here as it is
> > merely mindless chatter from lonely people.
>
> Why thank you. What a genuinely nice thing to say!
Derek; why don't you define mindless chatter? Some might consider your
above points mindless and something that should be directed towards
Gerry rather than the group. Stupid is as stupid does... > > >
I feel that Joel can post any
> > message he likes because he regularly contributes very valuable technical
> > information.
>
> Not to me, I don't have a Vanagon. In principle, I agree with you, though.
>
> > Some of the other people are just blowing hot air into this
> > thing and it has the potential to drive people with real jobs and real lives
> > off the list.
Derek please define hot air. What makes your points more valuable and
worth listening to?
>
> Now come on Derek, ALL of us have "real jobs and real lives". Yes, that
> includes Ric. :)
>
> > The saving grace is when people properly identify their subject matter. Those
> > of us who don't want to read poems about our campers have learned what Friday
> > Haiku means.
>
> Agreed.
>
> > Messages still go through here like "Glad to hear that," "I agree," or
> > "Thanks for all your help." I feel that if you have this little to say that
> > you should send a private message.
If I want to thank several people for advice I will do so en masse rather
than Individually. Sorry if you think thanking people is trivial....
> I bet a few of them were intended to be. It's entirely too easy to hit "r"
> to reply and forget that it is sent to the list. I've even done it a couple
> of times, and I do this stuff for a living.
>
> > Please don't generate traffic just to generate traffic. There are plenty of
> > places for that sort of thing in cyberspace.
How can you know this is what people are doing? The reason this list is
more interesting is that it crosses a greate divide of technical and
personal interests. If its technical information only you seek try
vintagvw. Can you say dull and repetitive?
>
> If I might add a little pet peeve of my own, Please also don't quote 80 lines
> of text and add 3 new ones at the bottom in your reply!!!! Even with a 56
> row window this gets annoying...
I did this once recently, precisely to point out how easily loads of
"infomation" can de shot down with one or two simple sentences.
> > -David
>
> =============================================================================
> David Schwarze '73 VW Safare Custom Camper (Da Boat)
> SAIC Comsystems, San Diego '73 Capri GT 2800 (Da Beast)
> schwarze@nosc.mil '87 Mustang Lx 5.0 (Da Bruiser? Soon...)
> =============================================================================
>
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
David Carment
School of International Affairs
Carleton University
Ottawa, Ontario
K1S 5B6
voice - (613) 788-2600-6662
fax - (613) 788-2889
Email address: dcarment@ccs.carleton.ca
----------------------------------------------------------------------
